ExamShortcut
medium importance~1-2 Q in Tier 18 formulas⚡ 4 shortcuts4 subtopics
Subtopic 4 of 4·← Three-circle counting

Choosing the correct diagram

🔒 Log in to track

For 'Which diagram represents Doctors, Men, Writers?' style questions, decide each pair with two tests:

  1. Necessity test — is every X definitionally a Y? (Every mother is a female.) → circle of X drawn inside Y.
  2. Impossibility test — can X and Y never share a member? (A square and a triangle.) → separate circles.
  3. Otherwise — overlap possible but neither forced (doctors and writers) → intersecting circles.

Same-type categories usually intersect; category-of-category pairs (squares/rectangles/polygons) nest; mutually exclusive definitions separate.

Detailed notes

What the question asks

You get three words (Doctors, Men, Writers; Even numbers, Odd numbers, Prime numbers) and must choose the circle picture that shows how the groups are related. There are no numbers — only relationships.

Two tests for every pair

Look at the three pairs one at a time: (1, 2), (2, 3), (1, 3).

  1. Inside test. Is every member of X always a member of Y? Every sparrow is a bird → the Sparrows circle is drawn inside Birds.
  2. Apart test. Can X and Y never share a member? No number is both even and odd → the two circles are drawn separate.
  3. If neither test holds, some members can be in both and some cannot → the circles intersect.

Judge by definition, not by what is usual. A doctor can be a woman and a woman can be a doctor, so Doctors and Women intersect.

The shapes that appear

RelationshipPictureExample
X ⊂ Y ⊂ Zthree nested circlesSparrows, Birds, Animals
X, Y separate, both inside Ztwo separate circles inside a thirdPens, Pencils, Stationery
X, Y intersect, both inside Ztwo intersecting circles inside a thirdEven numbers, Multiples of 3, Integers
X ⊂ Y, Z apart from bothone inside another, third separateWhales, Mammals, Fish
X ⊂ Y, Z crosses bothone inside another, third intersecting bothFathers, Men, Doctors
X ⊂ Y, Z crosses only Ythird cuts the outer circle onlyNatural numbers, Integers, Negative numbers
X, Y intersect, Z inside their overlapthird inside the common partMultiples of 5, Multiples of 7, Multiples of 35
X, Y separate, Z crosses bothtwo separate circles joined by a thirdEven numbers, Odd numbers, Prime numbers
all pairs intersectthree intersecting circlesTeachers, Women, Singers
two intersect, third aparttwo intersecting circles and a separate oneWomen, Engineers, Rivers
no linksthree separate circlesPens, Rivers, Tigers

Tricky cases

  • Number sets are exact: check a sample. 2 is even and prime, 3 is odd and prime, 9 is odd and not prime — so Primes cross both Even and Odd while Even and Odd never meet.
  • "Crosses only the outer circle." Negative numbers include −1 (an integer) and −½ (not an integer), and no negative number is a natural number. So the Negative circle cuts Integers but stays away from the Naturals circle inside it.
  • Inside their overlap. Every multiple of 35 is a multiple of both 5 and 7, so it sits inside the common part of those two circles.
  • Gender words. Fathers ⊂ Men; Mothers ⊂ Women; Men and Women are separate.

Method

  1. Write the three pairs.
  2. Mark each pair inside, apart or cross.
  3. Match the three marks to the picture — do not jump to a picture from the first pair alone.

Quick revision

  • For each pair: always both → inside; never both → apart; else → cross.
  • Judge by definition, not by what is common.
  • Test number sets with small examples (2, 3, 9, −1, −½).
  • A third circle can cross both, only the outer, or sit inside an overlap — check each pair separately.
  • Decide all three pairs before picking the picture.

Types of questions asked

Every way this subtopic shows up in exams — how to recognise it, the formula or logic to use, and a solved example.

Type 1: Nested chaincommon2 practice Q
How to spot it:

Each word is a type of the next: sparrow → bird → animal.

  1. Check that every X is a Y and every Y is a Z.
  2. Draw the circles one inside the next.

Why it works: subset of a subset is a subset.

Example: Sparrows, Birds, Animals.

Every sparrow is a bird, every bird an animal → three nested circles.

Type 2: Subsets inside a bigger setvery common3 practice Q
How to spot it:

Two words are kinds of the third word.

  1. Put both smaller groups inside the big circle.
  2. Decide whether the two smaller groups can share members: never → separate; sometimes → intersecting.
  3. If one group is inside another and the third is unrelated, draw the third apart.

Why it works: the relation between the two small groups is separate from their relation to the big one.

Example: Pens, Pencils, Stationery.

Both are stationery; nothing is both a pen and a pencil → two separate circles inside a third.

Type 3: Partial overlapscommon3 practice Q
How to spot it:

No word is a kind of another; some pairs can share members, some cannot.

  1. Test each pair: can share → intersect; never → apart.
  2. All three share → three intersecting circles.
  3. Two share and the third is unrelated → two intersecting circles plus a separate one.

Why it works: with no subsets, only the cross/apart choice matters for each pair.

Example: Teachers, Women, Singers.

Every pair can share members → three circles, each pair intersecting.

Type 4: Mixed: inside plus crossingoccasional4 practice Q
How to spot it:

One word is a kind of another and the third cuts across, or one sits inside the overlap of two.

  1. Draw the subset pair first.
  2. Test the third word against the inner and the outer circle separately.
  3. If the third word is a subset of two overlapping sets, place it inside their common part.

Why it works: the third circle's relation to the inner circle can differ from its relation to the outer one.

Example: Fathers, Men, Doctors.

Fathers ⊂ Men; a doctor can be a father or a man → one inside another, third intersecting both.

Shortcut tricks

⚡ Test one pair at a time

Never judge the whole picture at once. Run necessity/impossibility on each pair; the correct option is the only one agreeing on every pair.

Example: Q. Mothers, Females, Engineers.

Sol. Mothers ⊂ Females (necessity). Engineers ∩ Females possible (female engineers) and Engineers ⊄ Females (male engineers) → intersecting. Match the option reflecting both facts.

One wrong pair eliminates an option — work pair by pair until one option survives.

Where students lose marks

  • Drawing engineers inside females because most examples in mind are female.

  • Making mutually-overlappable categories fully separate.

  • Missing a third category's relation to the nested pair.

Practice sets — 15 questions

Sets of 10, mixed across the question types above. Each answer comes with a step-by-step explanation.

Topic test · 10 questions

Suggested time 7 min · wrong answers go to your mistake notebook automatically.